I first heard it Tuesday evening at the Age-Friendly Carbondale/Crystal Theatre Alliance watch party: “a blue wave.” By Friday, it seemed to be everywhere. But this is Mature Content. Having lived through 39 election cycles and voted in the last 22, the unrealistic elation worried me. 

Americans roundly rejected MAGA, mostly, because it didn’t deliver on its economic promises. Many voters were also fed up with the administration’s blatant corruption, lawlessness and cruelty. They wanted a secure border, but they didn’t think putting their long-time Hispanic neighbor in zip ties and hauling her away was the right way to secure it. They disliked Trump’s buddy, the world’s first trillionaire, spending a quarter of a billion dollars trying to buy an empire in Texas, while they were having a hard time buying gas to drive their kids to a playdate. 

But that didn’t make it a blue wave. This was essentially the same electorate that made Donald Trump president in 2016, and handed him majorities in both houses, shortly after he bragged about fondling women and claimed he could even publicly kill someone. Then that very electorate did it again in 2024, after he tried to invalidate the 2020 election, and, having failed, tried to overthrow the government by inciting a mob to storm the Capitol while Congress was in session. 

Obviously, a great many Americans were willing to put up with Donald Trump as long as they believed he cared about them and would help them pay their bills. Equally obvious, they had very little faith in Democrats’ willingness to treat them fairly. Most MAGA voters are decent people who feel left out of today’s America because, to a large extent, they have been left out of today’s America. 

But many anti-MAGA voters feel left out too. Though both major parties have strong bases, about a third of America’s roughly 212 million registered voters are, like me, unaffiliated. Include party members who consider themselves independents, and it rises to 45%. We are the ones who decide elections, and we don’t like or trust either party. This time around, we disliked Democrats (lots) less than we disliked Republicans, but we didn’t vote FOR Democrats. We voted against MAGA. Democratic sails happened to catch that wind. 

Fortunately, Democrats seemed to awaken from their happy delirium by the end of the weekend and began realizing that they had lucked into a two-year window to show they’ve relearned the art of governing. Moreover, I’m encouraged by the political and ethnic diversity of the people we chose. 

There’s a Christian moderate from Texas, a Muslim Social-
Democrat from Michigan, a Black minister from Georgia, Mississippi’s first Black senator since the Reconstruction era, a Yup’ik Native American from Alaska and others from varying backgrounds and with varying views. This colorful group will likely be led by a savvy, experienced Jewish New Yorker. The Senate may have as many as 25 women, and there will be more female representatives and governors than ever before. Can this diverse collection, which looks so much like the people who chose them, govern together? For the first time since 2008, when I had such high hopes for Obama, I’m optimistic. 

If they succeed in working together as Americans, Democrats are in an enviable political situation. For two years, they can stick to passing single-issue legislation that has wide popular support. They could restore Obamacare subsidies, reverse healthcare and nutrition cuts, reassert Congress’ constitutional power to declare war, raise income taxes for people earning over a half million dollars annually, guarantee a limited right to abortion, make immigration enforcement more humane, expand Medicare drug-price negotiations and more. 

If the president vetoes these things, Democrats can try to override, forcing Republicans to choose between him and the voters who want those measures. If he lets the measures become law, all the better. Either way, they win.

Making this strategy work will depend on Democrats cooperating more effectively than they have since the Great Society. Progressives and socialists will have to wait for complicated, expensive programs, like Medicare for All, and wait to tackle more divisive issues, like DEI, Israel, immigration reform and transgender rights. Meanwhile, moderates and conservatives may have to do more than they want to, even on these issues. The left has been waiting since the party shafted Bernie Sanders in 2016. They won’t wait forever. 

So, Democrats, I wish you the wisdom to make the most of your luck. And I have some asks.

Please, tell us clearly what you can and cannot try to do. Then do what you said. Call on us to endure when needed, but don’t expect us to endure while the super-rich get richer. Call on us for kindness, even when it’s not easy, and be kind to one another, even your opponents. Be brave. You don’t have to please all of us all the time. And finally, never, ever try to hoodwink us. If the midterms showed anything, they showed the emotional, physical and political costs that carries. 

In short, govern like the statesmen and women you can be. Americans want and deserve mature content.

Mature Content is a monthly feature from Age-Friendly Carbondale.