On Nov. 13, Thunder River Theatre Company (TRTC) and local playwright Kristin “K.D.” Carlson raised the curtain for a world premiere of her original piece, “Beyond Reason,” also debuting as the first fully-fleshed-out showcase from TRTC’s New Play Development Series.
“I had written and finished my first draft of this show in 2021, and had originally shown it to the inimitable Sean Jeffries, [former TRTC executive director]. Then when Missy Moore, [the current executive director], was developing the workshop, she said, ‘Hey, would you be my guinea pig with this wild thing you’ve written?’ And I was like, ‘Absolutely!’” Carlson shared.
Moore directed the piece, inspired by historical figures from the Spiritualism movement of the late 1800s. The story follows William James (Timothy Ackerman), an American philosopher and psychologist often revered as the Father of American Psychology, as he conducts an experiment at his home with the assistance of his wife, Alice (Jaspen Mackin, returning to the stage after a two-decade hiatus), and two psychic mediums, Leonora Piper (Brittany Crooke) and Gianina Provontsky (Nina Gabianelli), to provide scientific backing for being able to connect with matters beyond our ordinary grasp.
“The first reading of ‘Beyond Reason’ took place at TRTC and it featured the talents of Ryan Honey, Pax Wild, Trary LaMee and Nina Gabianelli, who is the only one of the original cast in this current chapter of the production. There are no background players; these folks are … front and center. What [audiences] are going to see really depends on what’s going on backstage, too,” Carlson shared.
Maizy Post makes her TRTC debut in this production as Lizzie Connelly, the housemaid for the James family. Carlson expressed how she couldn’t have been more satisfied with the cast and crew who put so many hours and suggestions into what has now been realized. Having seen the public production twice herself now, she is unequivocally happy with the outcome.
Had this reviewer not known of Mackin’s hiatus, it would have been assumed — even as a long-time theatergoer — that the audience was witnessing another brilliant performance from a seasoned performer. In fact, the whole cast’s chemistry had a sense of having been formed in a world beyond the living — which seems to be fitting.
Thanks to Jeffries’ set design expertise, the space was transformed to revive the period of history, permitting audiences to suspend their disbelief and be wholly present in the year 1886.
“The set design happened because Sean and I riffed on descriptive terms and we landed on ‘shattered’ and ‘broken,’” Moore explained, also noting that “Everything that we as a team have created was done truly by taking a leap of faith.”
“The creation of it all and the minutiae of the characters these actors have found has been such an incredible thing to see fully realized,” she continued. “After opening night, I left here feeling like I had given birth to a baby. There is no foundation to build on this play other than what we have all created together.”
One of the main themes that stuck out was how women’s influence was in a sort of limbo at the time of the Spiritualism movement. These women held much power in these spaces, but still lacked autonomy. Secondly, it was unexpected that the script’s balance of science and spirituality would rip through this critic with such a visceral reaction.
Grief and loss have a place in this production, revealed in greater depth in the second act. What goes hand in hand with that grief is how the patriarchal structure not only demonizes and systemically harms women experiencing it, but also programs men to push down and write off human experiences beyond logic and reason.
Carlson’s creation is something everyone should see; whether you’re a fan of the supernatural, historical fiction or know someone who is still fighting to be heard.
