Jake Skardon, courtesy photo

Restaurant Rating:

  • Cuisine: Pho and Japanese
  • Quality: 3.75/5

I’ve always believed that food, the making and eating of, is a team sport. More people equals more food and drink, which is an excuse for the individual to eat and drink more under the guise of sharing. However, not all foods lend themselves to cooperative dining. In my opinion, the sharing of soups, stews and anything liquid-based introduces challenging logistics to the restaurant-goer. Do you ask for more bowls? Do you risk splashing all over the table? Does one person extract all the good stuff, while the rest are left with broth?

These questions were to be answered at Kedai of Carbondale, the new tenants of the main street space formerly occupied by Allegria. A sister-location of the Glenwood favorite, Kedai specializes in pho, ramen and a number of non-liquid Japanese staples. 

I was out with a group of friends on First Friday when we swung by for an early dinner. Fortunately, we beat the crowds and secured a large table, perfect for spilling pho. We numbered six, and I could tell our waiter sensed trouble when we ordered three gourds of hot sake to start. While nothing fancy, these sake gourds were at least twice as large as the thin ceramic flasks found at other Valley restaurants. We had our work cut out for us indeed; as the first glasses were poured, I was somewhat apprehensive of the volume of liquid I would have to absorb that night.

We ordered a lot of food. To respect the restrictive word limit the editors have chained me to, I have boiled everything down to the highlights.

  • Chicken Gyoza: fried and steamed, one platter each. I preferred the soft chewiness of the steamed, as fried gyoza are more common, and therefore less ambitious. The chicken meat filling was ample, but not so flavorful.
  • Kedai Roll: I am lukewarm on “Americanized” sushi; the Kedai roll is loaded with cream cheese, tempura shrimp, jalapeno and a somewhat timid aioli sauce. The tempura shrimp was flakey, crunchy and melty, as it should be, while the glob of cream cheese provided a substantial bite to the roll.
  • Texas Roll: This roll was topped with thinly cut steak instead of fish, and filled with green veggies. While not really sushi, I did think the meltiness of the beef, coolness of rice and crunch of the veggies was delicious. Plus, it wasn’t covered in an aioli, so adding a splash of soy really brought out the steak.
  • Tokyo Roll: A typical spicy tuna roll topped with cuts of seared albacore. An extra fishy bite, I found this to be the least controversial and most filling sushi we ordered.
  • Spicy Tonkotsu Ramen: rich, creamy and loaded to the brim with toppings. The broth was strong, rich and hardy, a perfect winter treat, although hardly spicy. The cuts of pork belly were large and thick, and while charred a bit drier than I like, still very tasty. The noodles and veggies were in ample quantity, and the egg had the classic gummy yolk of traditional ramen. Overall a winner, and I am eager to try the other varieties of ramen they have in the future.
  • Pho: My good friend Ofek “B.,” esteemed outdoor athlete, legend on the ice and Valley microcelebrity, joined us on the pretense of grabbing a quick drink before leaving for a hockey game. But he was kind enough to stick around for the pho, of which he served himself 95% of the meat, slurping it down and fleeing before anyone noticed. The one sliver of beef that I got was oh so tender, moist, unapologetically beefy. I certainly would have enjoyed having a bit more. I am grateful that he left all the veggie toppings for us to munch on. You can’t win them all.
  • Spicy Samyang Noodles: The “spicy” ramen was fairly tame, so this plate of stir fried thick noodles, veggies and chicken would be safe, right? Wrong. I’d say I have a fairly high spice tolerance, but the intense oil lathered over the noodles left a deep burn in everyone’s mouth. To be clear, it tasted good, so good that it was worth crying, drooling and dripping snot. If this doesn’t sound like your thing, there are four less intense flavors of Samyang.
  • Chicken Currydon: This is a must order, 10/10 entree. Delicious fried chicken breast, coated in a thick curry sauce and chunks of stir fried carrot and onion. This is probably some of the best comfort food to be found in Carbondale, and when eaten with white rice, this is a truly filling meal.
  • Sesame Balls: Basically a donut filled with red bean paste, which seems a bit niche for Carbondale. Sweet bean treats are the only thing I remember about my middle school Chinese class (I certainly don’t remember any Chinese), so I absolutely loved this. Admittedly, it may not be for everyone, but it’s worth a try.

On sharing soups — the verdict is that soups should be enjoyed individually, or at most shared with one other person. It was far too easy for those with impure motives to hoard the good stuff, leaving only broth and bean sprouts for others. The passing around of bowls and serving spoons led to some sticky fingers and cross contamination, plus our table ended up very cluttered.

Overall, Kedai is a winner, striking a good balance of quality, quantity and cost. When the restaurant filled up, there was a fun energy and lots of chatter. The sake flowed like water. I found the sushi to be average, so I will probably stick to other dishes on future visits. However, the entrees were strong; each had a distinct, flavorful personality. Kedai is Carbondale’s newest go-to for fun, casual Asian dining, and I look forward to exploring more of the menu.